It's not any less useful than a plaque or other commemorative object.

If it was "Hanako bought this bottle" or any other character it'd be just as okay.

It is a sad day when a bottle of wine with a new sticker on it gets opposition in the NTSE forum.

Guys, seriously, it is labeled wine.

It isn't even a product being sold by a company, Wazu just relabeled some wine and I wanted a page to keep track of it. This would otherwise be a single line edit in an inventory page.

I'm annoyed that I have to even submit this for approval, but whatever. I am not going to get bent out of shape about it and we might as well have this conversation about what does and does not need approval to be changed on the wiki.


So what does constitute a setting element that needs to be approved? Factions, tech, customs, are all obviously fair game but where do we draw the line between a product and something like this?

(On a side note, what constitutes Yamatain law? There was a legal case somewhere the referenced a lot of laws that aren't part of Yamatai's legal framework...)

I think its kind of funny, actually. Very tongue in cheek and playful.

Wes, it's a sad day every day for your staff, and your lack of support for them.

Plaques and commemorative objects don't tend to screw with other players or characters the way this does. Thus, this submission gets flak for that.

If it was "Hanako bought this bottle" it'd be OK because you said it was. If that's how you want this to go, ask Gally for his opinion.

And last, but not least: Zack, that ruling was wholly grounded in quoted Yamataian law, not to mention other legal concepts (also quoted). When you take law and justice courses and learn better, you let me know.

APPROVED

It's a freaking wine bottle, and characters are allowed to make fun of each other.