Arieg
DEFCON Everybody Dies
Code:
The FM has spoken but I still has words to say to you Cedric.
First of all no one said that if there would be sub-division of marines, then they would be pulled from actuall units. THat is stupid, they would be taken from new recruits and trained for their tasks. Only peopel that would be pulled out are people who would actually train them, but hey guess what? These have to be pulled out to train Arieg's guard too. YOu cannot just hire some mercs for that. But we got over that anyway. Guard won't be subdivision of marines so I dunno why you took it out away.
Wouldn't that drain the Marines of replacements? Additional troops? As far as training I'm fairly sure there is more then enough retired veterans who'd be more then willing to sign on to defend their homelands by training their Guard forces or even leading them on a limited (weekend warrior) basis.
Code:
Another point, even if Cedric and Phaedr or other veteran soldier would be pulled out to serve in defense of planet that is not problem. So they would not like it? Who cares? THey are soldier they should listent to orders, shut up and do their works. Also yes Marines are current infranty of Nepleslia. They are NOT assault only. Marines pulled of defensive maneuver well before. Take evacuation procedures at Tok'Veru and Tange. And who do you thinkg mans current outpost? Penguins? No, the marines.
Those where tactical situations, and Rok'Veru was just a disaster all around. Just because Marines can be used in defensive roles doesn't mean they should, a good thought on that would be like using ferraris in a crash up demolition derby. Its a total waste to use them in that role.
Code:
Not to mention that I am very offended if you think me or Sigma does not know what hammer and anvil is and how it works. But guess what? That could be used with marines too. One unit of marines is deployed for defense and hold the enemy while, other stratecigaly inserts in Enemy is back or flank and hits them hard.
Yea.. and? The marines can't be everywhere and the concept is far more sound with an already established force on the ground.
Code:
That is about all I wanted to say. I am still on Cadet's idea of Guard being few patriotic kids with assault rifles trained to hold the enemy off until cavalry arrives. That would make for much more fun in any potential RP I think.
And.. I don't. A couple of kids with ARs and flak vests would last about as long as the Taliban did against the US and NATO in a stand up fight. To make this concept worth while without wasting the effort I'm going to go the whole nine-yards. The entire goal of this project is to provide the planets with something that can handle a small to moderate or even a large attack on their own with little to no assistance. If this goal is met it means the Navy and Marines can be used in a strategically offensive manner rather then having to worry about running back to the empire to dislodge an invasion force that has had days to entrench themselves.