I feel like the flag should have better colors than gray, and you might want to cut down the amount of symbols on it so it's easier to draw.
I have similar concerns over the name "Black Star" kind of overlaps with the "Star Army" and the "Black Claw" and as Zack mentioned, there's already a faction that uses a black star, which is Nepleslia. Side note: And I wouldn't suggest a red star either because it's so connected with IRL communism. I spoke with Arieg about that the other day.
But also I'm worried about the site being big enough to support all these new factions springing up, as the overall amount of players hasn't really grown since the time when there were only a few factions around. Balkanization of the plots, I worry, is trapping characters in factions where they can't easily leave a plot when they end or die out, like what happened with the Neshaten, and players are creating more characters in general, so they can put a foot in each faction, causing more posting responsibilities, which in turn may lead to burnout.
I think great factions great because they can work out their problems instead of everyone splitting off to do their own thing, thinking they can do better...because the endgame of that sort of thinking is everyone running their own little faction, factions that are weak because they don't have a sufficient amount of people running their workings. It's a classic "too many chiefs, not enough indians," scenario. And those type of factions in SARP have a proven history of dying as soon as the core creators become inactive (Abwehrans, UOC, Neshaten, Freespacers, Iroma, etc). Factions ending isn't necessarily bad if their story has been told and the RP was fun and has a conclusion, but in these examples they had players abandoned in the middle of unfinished RPs.
Additionally Nepleslia and Yamatai are also great factions because they are each the sum of over a decade's worth of content and lore building, and many many RPs that had life to their histories. It's really difficult to make a new faction, and I hope there's enough of you guys willing to really put it the work if you do this. Obviously everyone has to start somewhere but you'll have a long road ahead of you to get on Nepleslia's level, and don't expect to get "OG faction" treatment until you've proven this new faction is here to stay, which could be a while. It's hard not to compare this to Yamatai losing the UOC, and I know what it's like to be in Gunhand's shoes with plots walking. But the UOC did eventually earn my respect and I think if its leadership didn't vanish it could probably be here today.
I have also sent an email to the licensing department of Boy Scouts of America asking them if they have copywritten the initialism BSA in its entirety, and if not how we would be able to utilize it without breaching their trademark
Please do not act on my behalf concerning any legal issues relating to my site such as trademarks. I should be the only one to handle all legal matters for Star Army. If BSA is their trademark, we should not use it.